I don’t really know how to read Dostoevsky’s onion. I’ve gone back to it maybe a dozen times in the last few weeks, while my feed fills up with Neha Bora slipping out of police custody in Delhi and French teenagers with shattered jaws, and every time I can’t seem to untangle the web of thoughts that keeps getting stuck on the same parable. Since it won’t leave me alone, I’m going to try and think it through here.
Grushenka tells the story to Alyosha in The Brothers Karamazov. Once there was a wicked old woman who died without a single good deed to her name, and the devils threw her into the lake of fire. Her guardian angel, searching for anything to say in her defence, remembered that she had once pulled an onion from her garden and given it to a beggar. God told the angel to take that onion, hold it out to her, and pull. If it held, she could come out. So the angel pulled, and she began to rise, and the other sinners in the lake saw her lifted and caught hold of her to be pulled out too. She kicked them off. “I’m to be pulled out, not you. It’s my onion, not yours.” And the onion broke, and she fell back into the fire.
What bothered me first about this parable were the other sinners. One can assume they were burning in the lake alongside her because God had decreed that their actions deserved it. So if the wicked woman’s guardian angel got to fight for her, why weren’t the others given a similar chance? Didn’t they deserve to be pulled out as well, or at least get the opportunity? And then I realised that the wicked woman perhaps didn’t deserve the chance either. After all, one measly onion, given by a woman who did nothing else good in her whole life, barely meets the threshold for any chance at all. What I have since come to realise is that the onion was never a reward for one solitary act of goodness. It was a chance, held out to someone who hadn’t earned one, and she got it anyway. And the strange, almost democratic thing about the story is that it might have held them all. All those sinners writhing and clawing at each other, desperately trying to escape the consequences a deity had deemed fit for them. The onion didn’t snap under their weight or their struggle. It snapped the moment she decided who was worthy of it and who wasn’t.
That is the question I keep hearing asked about the people on the streets right now. Not what they want, but whether they deserve to want anything at all.
The world around us seems to be slowly burning and cannibalising itself, and nobody seems to care or even notice. This September in France, high school students in the poor northern suburbs of Paris barricaded themselves outside their schools to ask legitimate questions about missing teachers, overcrowded classes, systemic socio-economic disparity and an education that was falling apart. They were met with stun grenades and tear gas canisters. One fifteen-year-old lost his hand. A fourteen-year-old had his jaw shattered while he sat on a wall looking at his phone. A group of minors asked their government to take responsibility for their education and their future, and the police answered by arresting more than 6,500 people, most of them the very minors who were simply demanding to finally be heard. The right to an education and a stable life, apparently, is not a fundamental right at all but a privilege you should be grateful for. If you aren’t subserviently thanking your government overlords for the meagre onion they’ve held out, you are told how undemocratic and violent you are being. In the name of order, the police brutality is followed by night curfews across Paris and other cities, and a government spokeswoman asking what kind of parents let their teenagers burn bus shelters.
But is France the only country burning? Is Les Misérables 2.0 playing out only in the home of the most famous bourgeois revolution in Western history, the one that taught the rest of the world to shout liberty? Of course not. The whole world has turned into a burning lake of sinners.
In India, the Cockroach Janta Party was born from an insult, after the Chief Justice compared unemployed young Indians, clawing their way through an already rigged system in the hope of getting somewhere, to cockroaches. On Independence Day, the Prime Minister warned the nation of “dimagi Naxals” who had to be identified and isolated, and when people objected, they were told he had been taken out of context. But understanding the subtext of an obviously egregious speech is not the same as taking it out of context.
So the growing dissent, asking the state to account for the voters struck off its rolls and an exam system whose papers keep leaking, tried to gather at Jantar Mantar on the 10th of October. A ground built and designated specifically for protest. But why would a government that treats questions like terrorism against the nation allow dissent to exist, even there? Police stopped them before they could arrive. Human Rights Watch documented protesters being beaten and dragged through the streets, the internet shut off, journalists bundled into the same buses as the people they were reporting on, and three female journalists alleging they were sexually harassed by officers. “It needs twenty of you to carry a girl to a van,” as the writer Swarna put it. And the justification for all of it was that the protesters didn’t have permission, because their application asking for permission to protest was late. I don’t think I have ever written a more oxymoronic sentence in my life.
That is what these students and young people have been called. Cockroaches. A virus. Naxals. Savage hordes and pests, as two French police unions called the young people who rioted in 2023 after an officer shot seventeen-year-old Nahel. Sinners, in other words. These are verdicts handed down by people who have appointed themselves the almighty, deciding who deserves to be lifted out of the burning lake and who doesn’t.
But why is the youth of a country being compared to insects that need to be exterminated? Because they were apparently violent? Unruly? Lawless? Anti-national? “Violent” is a slippery word, as elastic as whoever is holding it needs it to be. A brick thrown at a police car is vandalism, while a police officer beating people with batons, blowing the hand off a child with a grenade and detaining journalists in buses is simply order, security and procedure. The moment the state can find a single instance of violence in a protest, everyone attached to it, the students sweltering in the heat, the women, the children, the working class, is turned into a mob, while a police officer beating someone half to death is a necessary precaution. Violence is a weapon for those in power, to wield as they please. It turns a question of rights into a question of character and respectability.
And this is where the parable starts to come apart in my hands. In the story, we never question that the people in the lake are sinners. We take Dostoevsky’s word for it, because it is God’s verdict, and God, at least, can see into a soul. The state can’t, and doesn’t bother to try. It simply calls you a cockroach or a Naxal and expects us to take its word as though it were God’s, and most of us do.
And Dostoevsky’s God is willing to let one measly onion undo a whole lifetime of wickedness. His onion is strong enough to hold every sinner in the lake, if only she would let them hold on. The state is not that God. It doesn’t just preside over the lake, but it keeps the fire burning. And when it holds out an onion, it isn’t trying to pull anyone out. It’s trying to keep them quiet. A designated patch of ground at Jantar Mantar that you aren’t allowed to reach. A curfew that gets called order. A few promises for the schools in the suburbs, and the expectation that you’ll be grateful for them. These aren’t rights. They’re pacifiers. Onions so thin they could only ever hold one person at a time, if that, which is exactly why everyone below is left fighting over them.
What is the onion then? Our fundamental rights? Or a benevolent second chance that should be accepted demurely, without question or complaint? Do we really have to deserve the onion through exemplary, virtuous behaviour, by staying in line? Or is it a right, like the right to learn, to vote, to speak, given to everyone regardless of how sinful their actions are?
The vote is the most basic onion a democracy holds out, and it is being taken back. In the first year of the Special Intensive Revision, almost six crore names were struck off India’s voter rolls. That revision is exactly what the Cockroach Janta Party is marching against, and somewhere in those six crore are people who have been declared dead and now have to prove they are alive enough to vote. It is very easy, if your own name is still on the list, to feel the onion firm in your hand and never look down.
Although I suppose sitting here writing my opinions is a lot easier than going out there and screaming them until people listen. I don’t know if I’d be brave enough to face the violence and stand on that line, because I can barely bring myself to argue with my own parents. I have tried enough times. It never goes anywhere, except leaving me so unsettled and hateful and baffled that I find it difficult to even look at them. Perhaps that’s why, a couple of days ago, when my parents were joking at dinner about how Muslim-free the streets of Aligarh are these days with Diwali approaching, I didn’t say anything. I paused for a moment, turned up the volume on my earphones and tried to simply finish my dinner. I don’t think there was any malice in my parents, at least not the intentional, calculated, hateful kind, and I suppose that is what unsettles me most. That people, afraid and confined to their own homes, can be a source of light merriment, and nobody at the table pauses to ask why. If it were us, shut indoors and confined to our backyards for fear of being mauled on the streets of our own city, I’m sure it wouldn’t be so amusing anymore.
I don’t think my family would be the wicked woman who kicks the others off. Because they wouldn’t even notice the people burning around them. They would simply look at the measly onion they’ve been handed, the quiet streets, the festival without “trouble”, the cheap tea-stall manufactured charisma that a whole generation of parents seem mesmerised by. They remain ignorantly thankful enough while everyone else burns. Because while Dostoevsky’s tale hinges on divine mercy, ours runs on control. While the parable’s cosmic system was generous enough to give an onion that would hold under the collective weight of a lifetime of sins, our modern gods, like the State of India and France, don’t hold out onions as instruments of liberation. Their pacifier was never going to pull anyone out of hell. It holds out bare-minimum concessions so the yelling public will be grateful and, more importantly, quiet.
The State doesn’t hand out rights. It hands out favours. It hands out superficial, perfunctory favours and demands absolute gratitude. And if the gratitude isn’t given appropriately, those favours are taken back.
But our terrible parable is not a fight against just our modern gods who would intimidate, assault, injure, prosecute and burn in the name of righteousness. It’s also with the wicked woman. The wicked woman is our cultural elite. The actors celebrating the Sangh’s centenary, the influencers issuing PR-washed abstractions or the billionaires building flying cars while the rest of us clamber to afford petrol for our beat-up cars. We should be grateful we had enough funds in our safety pot to pay lawyers and bail ourselves out of the police station. We should be grateful for the pacifier and drag and maim and scratch at each other for a chance to hold that onion, because despite appearances, not everyone is burning.
Not all silence and compliance is born of necessity, fear, or willful ignorance that treats a government as sacrosanct rulers. Rather, some of it is calculated, polished, and explicitly chosen.
The cultural elites blast their vacuous platitudes over television while making billions on the backs of people they can treat as a backdrop of disposable instruments. Thali ka baingan, rolling to whichever side the plate tilts. It’s baffling to me that an industry that claims to be built on expression and creativity is one of the most deceitful, spineless, self-serving cesspools I have had the misfortune of encountering. These cultural elites hoard power, privilege, and even rights while pretending to remain apolitical in a world where people are burning for their basic rights to education and to vote. They grab hold of the State’s pacifier onion, their wealth, their corporate endorsements, their political safety, and they treat it as a private prize.
When the youth on the streets grab at the edges of their comfort, demanding structural change, these elites don’t just stay silent. They get to rise above the pulsating bubble of hatred and injustice, and as they’re lifted, they kick down with their heavy boots at the hands reaching up, not wanting to be associated with the rebellious “sinners”. They would rather pretend to be oblivious than admit that the lake is on fire.
But then, what do the sinners burning in the lake do? Do we ignore those pacifiers, those frail onions meant to give false hope? Do we really have the privilege to examine the credentials of every guardian angel who reaches out? Which is why I might support Rahul Gandhi, a perhaps ordinary politician rather than a deviously manipulative one. Maybe Rahul Gandhi is only pretending to care. Jean-Luc Mélenchon has his own political agendas and an election that is making him march with abused French students. Maybe the guardian angel for us is not a caring, devoted protector who fights for us out of pure love. Maybe he has his own agendas and goals he is trying to achieve. But at least he’s doing his job, right? At least Rahul Gandhi is being the critical opposition he needs to be in a democratic nation. He’s a politician doing his job, and if I have to compare politicians to a guardian angel in a parable, then it tells you everything you need to know about where we are headed. I don’t need the opposition to be saviours. I need someone to be holding something out, and right now, they are almost the only ones who are.
However, Grushenka’s story is not a detached lecture on someone else’s wickedness, but rather a self-reflective, terrifying confession of how frail her own good deeds are. Isn’t that how we feel? I most certainly do. After all, I was silent at the dinner table. I didn’t put myself on the front lines. I turned up the volume in my earphones, decided to write this to assuage some guilt, and held onto my measly onion, my comfort, my safety, my refusal to start a family fight, and I looked away from the fire. I yelled for so long in the dark that I don’t even know if anybody can hear anymore, so perhaps I don’t try as hard to be heard. Isn’t that what we tell ourselves? That perhaps we are exaggerating. That maybe the noise around us is just noise. I still don’t know if my voice is strong enough to lift anyone out of the fire, or if I will ever find the courage to stand on the line. I only know how the story ends. The onion didn’t break when the others grabbed hold. It held every one of them, right up until she decided it was hers. It wasn’t their weight that broke it. It was her foot. And she doesn’t fall alone. Every hand that was holding on goes back into the fire with her, still reaching up.